← All episodes

193 - JOHN ELDREDGE | A Reckoning For Manhood

April 29, 2021 51m 00s Full transcript available
193 - JOHN ELDREDGE | A Reckoning For Manhood
0:00 / 51m 00s
In this episode, I sit down with John Eldridge to discuss the current state of manhood and the cultural chaos we're facing. We dive deep into the importance of courage, character, and the need for men to step up and lead in their families and communities.
Transcript
885 segments
0:00 When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed sponsored
0:05 jobs.
0:06 It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the
0:10 right skills, certifications, and more.
0:12 Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your
0:16 boxes.
0:17 Listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsor job credit at indeed.com/podcast.
0:23 That's indeed.com/podcast terms and conditions apply.
0:26 Need a hiring hero?
0:27 Yes, it's a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.
0:48 This is Undaunted Life of Man's Podcast.
0:50 I'm your host Kyle Thompson.
0:52 Let's get into it.
0:53 All right, guys.
0:54 Today we've got a special guest on the podcast for you and he is an alum of this podcast.
0:56 He is the Christian author, counselor and lecturer and that is John Eldridge.
1:00 So if you're not familiar with John Eldridge, where have you been?
1:03 What have you been doing?
1:04 You haven't been listening to this podcast.
1:05 He is a New York Times bestselling author of a large number of books and he's also got
1:08 workbooks and group studies and stuff like that.
1:10 But his newest bestseller is called Get Your Life Back Every Day Practices for a World
1:14 Gone Mad, which is very applicable for what happened in 2020 and certainly what's carried
1:19 over into 2021.
1:20 But he has written the seminal men's ministry book and I've said that over and over and
1:23 that is wild at heart.
1:24 So on our 100 books, every modern Christian man should read lists.
1:27 It's in my personal top 10 list.
1:28 So that's a book that you certainly have to read.
1:30 He's also authored some other books that we love here that you guys have read and loved.
1:34 That's beautiful outlaw, waking the dead, fathered by God, epic and he has many, many
1:38 others.
1:39 And he was on our podcast on episode 141.
1:41 So if you want to go check that out, you certainly should because in episode 141, we spend a lot
1:45 of time talking about the books, right?
1:47 We dug into a bunch of his different books and I asked him very specific questions.
1:50 I read quotes from those books and kind of went from there.
1:53 That's not what this interview was.
1:55 That interview was really good and you guys really enjoyed it.
1:58 This was something else entirely.
2:00 I wanted to kind of go into some other areas, some larger macro issues, culturally, spiritually
2:06 in terms of manhood and guys, this, this was a great conversation.
2:10 This was one of my favorite interviews that I've ever done and he actually turned the
2:14 tables on me at one point and he started asking me questions.
2:16 And so you should certainly stick around and listen for that.
2:19 And then also at the very, very end, I asked him about a very poignant and very awesome
2:23 quote from Jordan Peterson and you will not want to miss his feedback on that.
2:26 And guys, I'm not going to keep him from you any longer without further ado.
2:30 Let's get into it.
2:32 John Eldridge, welcome back to Daunted Life of Man's podcast.
2:36 Yeah.
2:37 Thanks, man.
2:38 Good to see you again, Kyle.
2:39 We are obviously very happy to have you back on because our guys freaked out the first
2:43 time we had you on.
2:44 It's like, Oh my gosh, how'd you make that happen?
2:46 They really, really enjoyed the interview, but this interview today is going to be a
2:49 little bit different.
2:50 That's the time we went through a lot of your books and we kind of dug in deep on some of
2:54 the books that are fan favorites of the people of this podcast.
2:57 We're going to do some of that today, but then we're going to get into some other deeper
3:00 issues.
3:01 So I'm sure you're going to be okay with that.
3:03 But the very first thing is the big news, which is you all have decided to relaunch
3:08 Wild at Heart.
3:09 Okay.
3:10 And so you've got a new cover for the book.
3:11 The book has been updated and revised and expanded.
3:15 You talked about that a little bit the last time that we had our podcast, then you also
3:18 launched the Wild at Heart experience right on your website, a six session video series
3:23 with a study guide to go along with it, kind of the whole nine.
3:26 But I don't want to take any of your steam here.
3:28 So what's different about this offering and how's it going to be beneficial to guys like
3:32 our listening to this?
3:33 Yeah, man, we, we saw guys getting pretty pounded through 2020 and into 2021, you know, we talked
3:41 about this before the anxiety, the depression, you know, the hopelessness, working from home
3:47 on your kitchen table on Zoom, even just all the crazy, right?
3:52 And we really wanted to make an offering to guys.
3:55 So we filmed this beautiful six part film series.
3:57 I mean, it's really gorgeous and we got it done during the pandemic.
4:01 We were able to do it last August, which was killer.
4:06 There was this window that we could get a film crew out and get into the woods and get
4:10 these different, you know, make it really gorgeous mountain biking, bow hunting, you know, make
4:15 it worth watching and, and then we decided, you know what, we're just going to give it
4:20 away.
4:21 Like put it online, make it free for guys.
4:24 So what it is, it's a, it's a six week journey you can do with us, you get on wallet heart
4:30 dot org, sign up for it for free.
4:33 And each week we, we deliver in your inbox, one of the sessions, but we also give some
4:38 scriptures, a reading that goes with it, some questions for reflection.
4:42 And then a special audio from me each week that says, okay, you know, we're here in week
4:48 two.
4:49 This is about the poser.
4:50 Let's be honest, you know, so it's a journey.
4:55 It's really meant to be more wholeheartedness for guys.
5:00 And we just thought, we thought the time was right.
5:03 Just given how tough the world has been on everybody, particularly men, like let's make
5:09 an offering, let's give something free away to guys that all bring some strength.
5:14 Well, I certainly think the timing is right, but I do kind of have to ask the, the pragmatic
5:18 business question side of it, which is just here recently, we, we announced that we're
5:22 expanding things considerably and we're going to be, you know, selling some things and trying
5:26 to create some things that are a value to people.
5:29 This is obviously of tremendous value.
5:31 And if you read any, you know, business one on one or marketing book or something like
5:34 that, it's like, you know, put a price tag on it because your time is worth something
5:37 and all this.
5:38 And it kind of walked me through just the business side of it, like why create something
5:42 that is so gorgeous.
5:43 I watched these videos.
5:44 They're, they're absolutely fantastic.
5:46 Why put it out there for free?
5:48 That's what my publisher is asking.
5:51 Okay.
5:52 At least it's not crazy.
5:55 You know, um, we don't, we wanted no barrier to entry.
6:00 We wanted just no hurdle, nothing, no other agenda in it.
6:04 I believe, I believe that you're worth your time, Kyle.
6:07 I believe that there's value in, in, in what we do.
6:11 And so, you know, my books are for sale on Amazon and that sort of thing.
6:16 But this particular moment and this particular offering, we just said, you know what?
6:22 Let's give a gift to guys.
6:24 And, and it's really true, like it's better to give than to receive.
6:28 It's just a joy to put it out there for stinking free.
6:33 I'm sure that's got to be exciting for you.
6:34 Because I, I told you this off air, but you let me have access to the videos prior to
6:38 the launch, which I really appreciate being able to see that just so I can make fun of
6:41 my friends that didn't have access.
6:42 That's the main reason why I enjoyed it.
6:44 But aside from that, when I got on your website and saw that everything was free, I was like,
6:48 okay, they're doing something different now.
6:50 Like they're, they're, they're really trying to make an impact.
6:52 And later on, I've got some questions that are kind of questions for this moment and
6:57 we'll kind of get into that.
6:58 But I guess to wrap up the, the wild at heart thing is it's, it's got to be at least a little
7:02 bit weird and a little bit humbling that people are still buying and responding to wild at
7:08 heart.
7:09 Right.
7:10 I mean, we live in a world, John, where the morning's news is forgotten before lunchtime,
7:13 right?
7:14 Like everything just moves out of breakneck speed and you've talked about that in some
7:17 of your books, but a 20 plus year old book is still having this large impact.
7:21 I mean, walk me through how you even feel about that.
7:24 Well, it's a God story.
7:27 I mean, that's all there is to it, that in this moment of cultural crisis, in this moment
7:34 of gender crisis, God knew and he teeted up and the way he teeted up, like with the
7:41 clients that I was working with at the time of writing the book, with all the things we
7:46 were doing, raising boys, he set it up.
7:51 And I think he set it up for now, like it's, it's been on this trajectory around the world.
7:57 It's not seen a dip like that.
8:00 And in the bottom, the bottom line is as it works, like it heals, it strengthens.
8:06 It provides fathering where guys didn't get that it works.
8:11 And so one guy tells another, tells another, tells another, you know, just father's giving
8:16 it to sons and guys, you know, just like in your group, right?
8:20 One guy gives it to another and he reads it and he goes, oh my gosh, my brother needs
8:24 to hear this.
8:25 And so, yeah, it works.
8:27 That's the why.
8:28 Well, I told you this, I think in our last time that we, our last interview rather, that
8:32 we reread that book at our foxhole group, right?
8:37 And so a lot of us were kind of like, yeah, wow, it's hard.
8:39 I mean, been there, done that.
8:40 We've read it before.
8:41 Most of us have read it multiple times.
8:42 And then we reread it again.
8:44 It's like, oh, okay, this stuff is super applicable, even more so now because of some of the things
8:50 going on culturally, which I don't want to get the cart before the horse here because
8:53 I did want to do something a little bit new with you, if that's all right.
8:56 So we have just recently started taking donations to kind of grow what we're doing here with
9:00 undaunted life.
9:01 And we have monthly partners.
9:02 We have people that have partnered with us to help us push back darkness.
9:06 And so if you want a little bit more information on that, just go to undaunted.life/donate.
9:10 But I asked some of our first donors, right?
9:13 These people that were ready to go, they're like, how we're ready, we're raising our hand,
9:16 we're going with you.
9:17 And I asked them if they could ask John Eldridge, one question, what would that one question
9:21 be?
9:22 So I got a lot of responses from these guys.
9:23 So you cool with going over some of their questions?
9:25 All right.
9:26 Here we go.
9:27 Okay.
9:28 So the first one is from a guy named Adam Smith.
9:29 And so thank you very much, Adam Smith, for being a monthly partner with us.
9:33 But here's his question.
9:34 How do we respond to people in today's society who call us close-minded bigots for believing
9:40 that the Bible teaches that a man is a man and a woman is a woman?
9:46 Yeah, well, here's the deal.
9:50 There is so much hatred in the world right now that as we stand our ground, as we try
10:00 and explain to people that this is real, you can see it in the science, you can see it
10:05 in the brain, you can see it in psychology, you can see it in the patterns of how you educate
10:12 boys and girls.
10:13 I mean, it's everywhere.
10:14 We're not making this stuff up.
10:17 You got to do it with grace, like be gracious.
10:21 The scripture says a gentle answer turns away wrath.
10:26 And there is a truckload of wrath out there.
10:30 So I would combine that with the idea that Jesus said he has ears to hear, let him hear.
10:38 I can tell when I'm in an interview or a conversation, when I'm getting my haircut or I'm down at
10:45 the auto parts store, I can tell, is this guy, is this gal really open to hearing?
10:51 Or are they just pushing back?
10:53 And if they're open, right, you can go, well, it's actually pretty beautiful.
10:57 Gender has got a lot of dignity to it from God.
11:00 If they're not open to it, I would say, don't bother.
11:03 Yeah, it's Pearl's before swine at that point.
11:06 It's not going to go well.
11:07 So I would just say something like, you know what, we're just out here trying to help some
11:12 guys that are curious with what we're doing, but if it's not for you, it's not for you.
11:16 And I think when people hear, you're not trying to shove this down my throat, they go, Oh,
11:25 I mean, even if they're not interested, yeah, so a gentle answer turns away wrath would be
11:29 what I'd say.
11:30 Well, so to that, just as a quick follow up, because I don't want to take any time away
11:34 from the other guys that want to get their questions in.
11:36 So could sometimes the gentle answer just be no, I've talked to so many guys whose school
11:43 districts are kind of bringing in LGBTQ books into their library for, you know, the elementary
11:48 school kids and stuff like that.
11:50 So perhaps the gentle but forceful answer could be no.
11:54 Could it not?
11:55 Oh, yeah.
11:56 Oh, yeah.
11:57 Yep.
11:58 Absolutely.
11:59 But, but again, like pick your fights, pick your fights there, there is, there are people
12:09 who really are looking and they're and they need some answers, especially like parenting
12:15 boys, that kind of thing, they're looking for answers.
12:18 And there's there's a lot of people out there that just want an argument and it's not worth
12:23 your time.
12:24 It's not worth your time.
12:25 All right, sounds good.
12:26 We'll get to the next question here.
12:27 And this one is from Greg Jarrett.
12:28 So Greg, thank you for being a monthly partner with us.
12:30 And this is his question.
12:31 And it goes back to something you mentioned earlier, John, given the shift to work from
12:34 home and virtual school, it feels as if our dependency on technology the past year has
12:39 accelerated.
12:40 If you could add a new chapter to your book, get your life back due to the events of the
12:45 last year, what advice or guidance would you add?
12:49 Well, okay.
12:51 So a lot of us now are committed to it and you and I are right now.
12:55 We are online getting our work done, right?
13:00 So I would say you've got to break it up.
13:04 First off, break it up if you can.
13:06 Like when I'm done with this interview, before I go on to the next thing, I'll literally
13:10 just walk outside, chuck the ball to the dog, you know, and I literally like get my hands
13:15 in the earth.
13:16 I need to do that, like reconnect with reality.
13:21 So break it up if you can.
13:22 Do these five, six, seven hour stints, like in screen time.
13:27 Second thing is now you know how much more important it is that when you are done, you're
13:32 done.
13:33 And so switch your entertainment, guys, like if you're on technology all day for work,
13:40 don't make technology your downtime in the evening, you know, build something, model airplanes,
13:46 you know, fix your chainsaw, put in, you know, spark plugs in the lawn more, like just do
13:51 real stuff.
13:53 And I'm going to throw a little, a little tidbit in here because I've been really struck by
13:56 this.
13:57 I was reading a study that was talking about the mental, again, the mental health effects
14:01 of the pandemic and all that on us.
14:04 And it was, it was talking about the human brains need to achieve, achieve real goals.
14:11 And so it for guys, this is huge because we love to fix stuff, honestly, fix stuff, fix
14:19 the toaster, put a new light switch in, paint a room, like I'm serious, like every week,
14:25 you've got to be doing stuff that's real where you're winning.
14:29 You know, even if it's, even if it's dumb stuff where you're like, put in a new light
14:33 switch, I'm telling you, it's going to bring you joy because the masculine soul needs to
14:38 do real stuff and feel like we're making progress.
14:41 So now in the evening, you're going to switch to, you know what, I'm going to actually go
14:45 back down to the batting cages.
14:47 I used to do that in high school, I loved it, I've been there for years.
14:50 I'm going back down.
14:51 I'm like, we're just going to slump some balls so much better than, than, you know, technology
14:56 all the way to bedtime.
14:57 That's a great way of thinking about it because there are a lot of days, John, where I hit
15:01 my, my head's about to hit the pillow and it's like, Oh, this thing has been in my hand
15:05 all day.
15:07 And I say it's because I needed that, right?
15:09 But I didn't need every last second of it.
15:11 But yesterday when I was digging holes in my backyard to set traps to try and kill the
15:15 stupid gopher that's putting mounds in my yard, that, that was me getting in there and like
15:20 being completely unplugged before this interview, I was doing jujitsu.
15:24 You can't have your phone out there.
15:25 You can't live tweet a jujitsu session, right?
15:27 Like it's doing something tangible and even if you get whooped and even if I don't catch
15:31 the gopher, it's still doing something with my hand.
15:34 So I certainly appreciate that sentiment.
15:36 So the next question here is from a guy named Chris Zurzavi.
15:38 So thank you, Chris Zurzavi for partnering with us.
15:40 And it's a really interesting question.
15:41 This is it.
15:42 Did Jesus were to disciple men directly today like he did with his disciples?
15:48 What lessons do you feel would be the most prominent in Jesus' teachings for inciting
15:53 change in the current state of our society?
15:57 Oh, man, that is a brilliant question.
16:03 I honestly, I think he would start with rage.
16:10 Meaning, what are you going to do with your rage?
16:16 Because there is so much wrong right now with the world and there is so much falsehood.
16:24 And you guys, you're in all this.
16:26 You read the news.
16:27 You see it.
16:28 The censorship, all that, like again, in the masculine soul.
16:32 And I think this is what really fried guys in the last year is that we are so wired for
16:39 the fight to make a difference, to bring good, to bring breakthrough, truth, healing, redemption,
16:47 healed marriages, great kids, all that.
16:50 We're so wired for the fight that when we can't fight because it's just so out there,
16:58 it's ethereal, it's in the hands of the media or whatever, like there's a lot of anger that
17:03 gets built up.
17:05 I think Jesus would really help us say, look, you're in a super tough moment right now where
17:12 a lot seems out of your control.
17:15 Let's start with anger and how to handle it well and disciple us in that.
17:24 So it doesn't get the best of us because, man, I could feel it this morning.
17:29 I could feel it this morning that hatred wants to get inside us so that we answer with hatred.
17:39 I can feel it, guys, like I was [inaudible] and I could feel, I'm like, wait, hang on a second.
17:48 There is an appropriate place for anger, but don't let the hatred in.
17:53 Don't let it into your heart because then they want, then they want, right, and you're
17:59 taken out that way.
18:00 So I think he'd start with that and then I think he would, honestly, here's where the
18:07 battle is going to get one.
18:09 It's going to get one in the neighborhood and it's going to get one in small groups of
18:15 guys doing stuff together, like my neighbor across the street is a great guy.
18:24 And I've built some rapport with him over the years.
18:27 So over the pandemic, when he was totally locked down, I gave him while at heart and
18:30 I said, hey, you're bored.
18:31 You're looking for something to do.
18:32 Read this.
18:34 And here's the cool story.
18:35 He got back to me.
18:36 It's about halfway through.
18:37 He's like, oh, dude, we need to get on my porch.
18:39 We need a lot of fire in the fire pit.
18:42 We need to have some beers.
18:43 We need to talk about that.
18:44 Yeah.
18:45 And like, that's it.
18:46 That's it.
18:47 Man to man, life to life, neighborhood to neighborhood.
18:49 This is where it's going to happen.
18:50 Honestly, it's not going to happen in the media.
18:53 That's not where the battle is going to get one.
18:55 It's going to get one life to life.
18:57 And the good news is that we got that, like we can do that.
19:01 Right.
19:02 That is within our effective sphere of influence.
19:05 We can do that.
19:06 So I'd say small groups of guys doing cool stuff that invite other guys into it.
19:11 Well, one of the things, John, that I think happened in 2020 as well, is I think people
19:15 for the first time learned the name of their mayor and their city counselor and their sheriff.
19:22 And it was because all these rights were potentially being taken away from them in their communities
19:26 or their school board, which is five people and a three to two vote allowed some of this
19:30 nonsense to happen.
19:31 People are all of a sudden, wait a minute, wait a minute.
19:33 I was worried about Trump's Twitter, right?
19:35 I was worried about, you know, what Kamala Harris might do whenever she takes over and
19:40 is no longer co president, but is actually president.
19:42 And then they realize it's like, wait a minute.
19:44 There's stuff happening in my community that I had a vote.
19:47 I could have actually changed some people.
19:49 I could have talked to some people in the neighborhood and maybe shifted 10 a dozen votes
19:53 to a better way of doing things.
19:55 And so I think that's been something for guys to kind of bring it down to the granular level,
19:59 which is like, hey, as long as it's righteous indignation, that means you can use that anger
20:04 to fuel you in a positive direction.
20:06 But if it's just misguided, then we have an issue.
20:09 Yep.
20:10 Yep.
20:11 Right on the movement, the movement is always grassroots.
20:15 Absolutely.
20:16 All right.
20:17 Next question here.
20:18 And this one is from Reg Aldrich.
20:19 So much for partnering with us.
20:20 This is his question.
20:21 It's a simple one.
20:22 How do you effectively balance the personal pursuit of manhood with the development of
20:27 your family?
20:28 Yeah.
20:29 Right.
20:30 Oh gosh.
20:31 This is every guy's deal here in a lot of it depends on the age of your kids.
20:37 Because when you're in the, when you're in the grade school, you're in the young, you
20:40 know, the Lego years and the, you know, soccer and baseball and music and all that.
20:47 It's rough and I have three sons and two of them are at that stage right now.
20:52 They're 30, 32, they're, they're just in it.
20:55 And so I would say it's the early morning run.
21:00 It's the once a week, you know, at the dojo, it, it, you're going to, you're going to have
21:05 to carve it out, recognizing it's not everything you want.
21:10 And I want to say to those guys, it gets better.
21:14 It gets better.
21:16 It really does.
21:17 Because as your kids get a little bit older, a little more independent, they want to see
21:21 their friends, their sleepovers, da, da, da, da, da, suddenly you're like, whoa, I just
21:26 got a 30 Thursday night off.
21:28 And then you grab it, you grab it for your soul.
21:32 You grab it for what you're doing.
21:33 You get out in the yard and shoot your bow, you, you know, get out and hit a bucket of
21:38 balls or whatever.
21:40 Kindness, guys, kindness to yourself, because it's so frustrating that you can't get it
21:48 all in.
21:51 And this isn't about getting it all in.
21:53 It's finding the margins where you can get some life for your own soul.
21:59 Well, I feel like that was the message I needed because I just told you I went to jujitsu.
22:03 That might be the only class I get in this week.
22:05 And it's just like, I'm getting worse.
22:08 All these other people are getting better, but I also have to realize that guy that's
22:11 getting better is 22 single and has a part time job.
22:14 So he can live at the gym.
22:16 That's the why he's getting better.
22:17 So, you know, in this season of life, okay, all right, I'll have to chew on that one a
22:21 little bit more, but I, something tells me you're probably right, but that's frustrating.
22:26 But I appreciate it.
22:27 All right.
22:28 Last question that we have from one of our listeners, and this is from Ryan Horn.
22:31 And this was his question.
22:32 How can I, as a father, biblically raise my son to be a leader while living in a culture
22:37 that is set on a masculation and the demonization of patriarchy?
22:42 Yeah.
22:43 So again, grassroots, first off, that you want to either build or find the kind of community
22:54 immediately around you, your immediate friends, the play groups, the other dads, their sons,
23:00 that are living in what you want, right?
23:03 So that his initial experience is growing up, you know, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, it's just,
23:08 it's just a company of men who all believe this, and he understands, oh, this is the
23:14 way we're wired.
23:15 There's a lot of affirmation, there's great experiences, there's shared adventures.
23:20 So you know, you start with that circle of influence, the immediate, and if it's toxic
23:26 there, oh man, like you got to change that.
23:31 And you may need to set some family boundaries and say, you know, I love your uncle, I love
23:36 your brother, you know, but we can't hang out with them every weekend.
23:40 They are super toxic people.
23:42 So you do have to create that initial circle of community support, and it's a couple of
23:48 pals for him and a couple, it's not huge, it's not hundreds of people, but in your immediate
23:54 barbecue circle, your picnic circle, your hangout circle, right?
23:58 These are people who know and love what you know and love, and they're affirming it in
24:03 your son.
24:05 And then you begin to give him, he's got to get stretched, masculine, he's all about
24:13 getting stretched, right?
24:15 So then it's, hey, this came up in class this week, I don't know how to answer this, let's
24:22 sit down and talk it through, what would be the best way?
24:25 And it comes back to some of that stuff about a general answer, it turns away rat and that's
24:29 kind of like showing him the power of self control.
24:32 Scripture says that the man who controls himself is greater than a warrior who wins an entire
24:37 city.
24:38 And so showing him those lessons of, I know that makes you mad, I know let's figure out
24:44 a really cunning way to answer that.
24:47 And if the teacher is hostile, how do we disarm him or her?
24:51 How do we become their friend?
24:53 What if we invite your teacher over to dinner, but like showing him the brilliant way?
24:59 So Jesus says, I want you to be as innocent as doves and shrewd as serpents, like guys,
25:07 you got to teach your kids that this is a world that requires cunning.
25:14 And quite often that means the indirect approach, there was a whole book written on this by
25:20 that title, the indirect approach about how you win wars, how you win arguments, how you
25:25 win people.
25:27 And it's very rarely kicking down the front door.
25:31 People just don't respond to that well, systems don't respond to that well.
25:35 But you come in the side door, you find out that your teacher, she loves gardening.
25:41 And so for a teacher's day or whatever, you get her some plants.
25:46 And they're like, wait, what, like you actually care about me, you're not just interested
25:51 in winning the fight and you're showing your son the brilliant way.
25:56 You're like, how can we disarm this and win some influence here so that when you get up
26:02 to give your book report, she's listening, right, and you get your chance to make your
26:07 point.
26:08 Absolutely.
26:10 I lied.
26:11 There is one more question.
26:12 And this is perhaps the most meaningful question that I got from any of our listeners,
26:16 John, and it's this, bourbon or scotch?
26:19 I mean, we need to know the answer to this.
26:23 Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's all it's all in the consumer.
26:28 It's all in the taste buds.
26:30 I am not a bourbon guy.
26:33 I have friends who are love it.
26:36 I just don't and I know what it actually, wow, I didn't even I didn't even track this
26:41 until this moment.
26:43 So my dad was an alcoholic and his deal was bourbon.
26:47 And so I just think the smell for me, like the certain aroma, I just think I just immediately
26:52 like, no, not, not interested there.
26:55 Yeah.
26:56 Okay.
26:57 So while we're doing the interview, I just got on your website.
27:01 I found the donate page and I clicked the $100, put my credit card in.
27:06 I just donated to undaunted life.
27:08 So I'm now a supporter.
27:09 So do I get to ask a, I guess so those are the rules that I made up here.
27:13 They're on the spot.
27:14 But hey, hey, thank you, John, the elders for being a donator to undaunted life.
27:18 So go ahead, fire away.
27:20 Here's my question.
27:21 My question is, what are you going to do for joy this summer?
27:26 What's the family plan for joy?
27:28 So that is actually a fantastic question because, and I know you're doing that on purpose because
27:31 I don't consider myself a joyful person or someone that searches for joy.
27:35 But this is something I'm honestly excited about.
27:37 My son's turning one years old May 7th and he's been very sick for, for a long time.
27:42 He was just at the doctor again today.
27:44 Can't get his, his ears figured out fluid, you know, fevers, all kinds of crazy stuff.
27:49 But assuming we can get all that under control.
27:51 The thing I'm most excited about is doing the things during the summer that I don't
27:56 normally do myself, but I want to do with my son.
27:59 So I'm a ginger for those of you that are not list that are, aren't watching this or,
28:03 you know, listening to it.
28:04 So I don't like the sun that much.
28:06 So I will mow the lawn in a hoodie.
28:07 I don't even care.
28:08 But I'm going to go to the pool with my boy and we're going to hang out the pool and he's
28:13 going to wear a tank top and he's going to show off the guns for the ladies and it's
28:16 going to be great and we're going to have a good time.
28:18 And he should be walking maybe around that summer.
28:21 And so for me, I look back on my father and even with all of his faults and all the shortcomings,
28:27 most of which he would admit himself, the thing that he always was for me was present.
28:32 He was there.
28:33 Not only was he at every game, John, he was at every practice, right?
28:37 He sacrificed so that he could watch his boy, do whatever his boy wanted to do.
28:41 And so I want to kind of start that even the summer, you know, he doesn't exactly remember.
28:46 I'm not able to kind of, hey, read the communist manifesto and let's talk about it next week.
28:49 Like I can't have those types of theoretical conversations.
28:53 But for me in my house, we intend to have a very joyful summer outdoors.
28:57 Right on.
28:58 You know what?
28:59 Guys, listen to this.
29:00 The best investments you can make is that $15 plastic kitty pool, right?
29:08 I'm telling you guys, you get a lawn chair.
29:11 You put your feet in the kitty pool.
29:13 You let the kids hang out in it.
29:15 It's joy.
29:16 Like just goofing off like, yeah, that's a good plan.
29:20 It's funny you bring that up because my wife yesterday was like, because it's cold right
29:23 now in Oklahoma.
29:24 It's like 40 something degrees.
29:25 But she's like, hey, we needed to go get one of those little kitty pools and just toss
29:28 in the backyard.
29:29 We're not at the big pool.
29:31 We can just sit there and literally do what you just said.
29:33 So that is very interesting.
29:34 But hey, again, thank you very much for supporting us.
29:37 And hey, if you want to throw in another hundred bucks, I could probably take another question.
29:40 You know, I'm over.
29:41 Give me another question.
29:42 Next.
29:43 Next.
29:44 Okay.
29:45 I'll let you think through it.
29:46 All right.
29:47 So I want to kind of, I want to kind of shift through.
29:48 And so this is, this is kind of getting into the world of the theory.
29:49 Ethereal.
29:50 You brought that up a little bit earlier.
29:51 But you're, you're someone that is very, very much so in tune with prayer and God giving
29:56 you words or giving you phrases and then you will kind of sit on those and meditate on
30:00 those.
30:01 That doesn't happen for me as often.
30:02 But I feel like it hit me between the eyeballs yesterday.
30:06 And so I'm just going to throw this out there.
30:07 I don't even have a question prepared.
30:08 I'm going to throw out what I think God was telling me while I was preparing for this
30:12 interview, I feel like God put this short thought on my heart and it's that this.
30:16 There is a reckoning for manhood on the horizon.
30:21 And the emphasis in my brain was reckoning, right?
30:23 You know, manhood on the horizon that shows that it's imminent and all that.
30:27 But hearing me say that there is a reckoning for manhood on the horizon.
30:31 What does that bring up in you?
30:39 Quite a bit actually.
30:43 So let's chase a couple threads of that.
30:50 The first one is courage.
30:56 The amount of fear that has swept through the world, and we talked about this, you know,
31:03 that was out for a hike in the woods.
31:06 I am in the woods.
31:09 And here comes a hiker with a mask on.
31:12 And it was a young woman.
31:13 She was in great shape.
31:15 She was beating me and I just felt so bad for her.
31:21 I didn't want to shame her.
31:22 I didn't want to blame her.
31:23 I didn't want to start an argument with her.
31:24 I just felt so bad for the fear that has gripped her.
31:30 Fear has really swept the world.
31:33 And I think part of the reckoning is the courage that is required of men in a world
31:43 that is going sideways.
31:46 And so connected with that is the courage to believe, the courage to believe.
31:58 Paul says in 1 Corinthians 15, be steadfast, immovable, steadfast and immovable.
32:07 It's such a masculine thing to be a rock, to be a rock for your family, to be a rock
32:13 for your friends, for your community, in a world that's going nuts.
32:19 So those are couple of threads.
32:21 The other thread that comes to mind, Kyle, is your character.
32:28 Guys, this is no time to dink around with your character.
32:35 I know too many stories.
32:39 And we sit in a position where we get a lot of these stories because we're connected to
32:43 the men's movement around the world.
32:45 But man, good men blowing up, blown up the marriage, divorce, having an affair, blowing
32:56 up online, blowing their lives up.
33:02 If there is a reckoning coming, I will guarantee you that your character will be tested.
33:12 And your character is what will see you through it.
33:16 And so don't dink around with your character.
33:20 Like honestly, humility, integrity, holiness, love, like you can't compromise on those things.
33:30 Right, some of them came to mind when you said that, John, is I go all the way back to
33:34 a podcast episode I did after the country of Ireland legalized abortion.
33:39 And the big through point as to why that was able to happen was because the Catholic church
33:44 had completely lost its place in the country of Ireland to where most people were like,
33:49 "Oh, wait a minute.
33:50 Y'all were the ones that were raping boys and then just moving the people around so no
33:53 one would get caught.
33:54 Yeah, up yours.
33:55 I'm not going to listen to you about what I should do in terms of voting for abortion."
33:58 The same thing for us as men, if we're going to be pushing back on darkness culturally,
34:02 spiritually, you know, whatever, then we have to make sure our house is in order.
34:07 Because if someone can easily take out our knees because we live in a post truth culture,
34:11 so a lot of times you're like, "Well, what I'm saying is true.
34:13 That doesn't matter anymore to a lot of people," right?
34:16 It matters what fits their narrative.
34:18 And so with that in mind, we've got to be able to push back and understand that what's
34:22 undergirding what we're saying is truthful while at the same time recognizing that we're
34:27 not perfect and we have to be covered by the blood of Christ.
34:30 And that actually dovetails nicely into kind of what I wanted to ask you next.
34:33 And this could go a million different directions and we could have spent the entire time today
34:36 just talking about this.
34:38 But I wanted to get your thoughts on kind of the "woke" church movement.
34:43 So critical theory, specifically critical race theory, seems to be working its way into
34:48 a lot of denominations and to a lot of congregations individually.
34:52 There are a lot of well-meaning Christians that don't know what to do with that.
34:56 They haven't read white fragility.
34:59 They haven't read Ibermec's Kennedy.
35:01 They haven't read any of these people.
35:03 They haven't read any of the counterarguments from a Vodie Bakkam or from a John MacArthur
35:07 or something like that.
35:08 And so what are your thoughts in terms of what that's going to potentially do to the
35:13 American church?
35:14 Maybe the church writ large and what we could as men do to affect that?
35:25 So this is a three-part podcast, right?
35:27 You understand that these questions are so huge.
35:30 This is all part of my plan, John.
35:32 I just want you to keep coming back because we weren't able to solve all the problems.
35:35 So that's certainly part of the plan.
35:38 So it depends on who you're talking to is the answer.
35:48 First off, you cannot come across as being opposed to justice.
36:01 Now I know you're not.
36:02 I know you're not, guys.
36:03 I know you're not.
36:05 But you've got to understand that out there right now, there is a hair trigger that if
36:12 you seem in any way opposed to the pursuit of justice, there's actually something really
36:21 evil at work in the world right now.
36:23 And I'm just trying to figure out how to put all this into an answer.
36:28 What the world is trying to do is arrange for the kingdom without the king.
36:34 They want the kingdom without the king.
36:37 They want all of the justice and equality and reparations that the kingdom of God actually
36:44 brings, right?
36:46 I mean, we will love one another, every tribe, tongue, and nation.
36:50 Like God's got this fabulous racial theory, right?
36:54 We are his sons and daughters.
36:58 What they want is the kingdom without the king.
37:00 And when you start insisting on that, the end result is a sacrificial system.
37:10 Somebody gets thrown under the bus and it will probably be conservatives.
37:18 So you've got to be really aware that this is operating in the world right now so that
37:26 you won who are you talking to?
37:31 Is this your rector?
37:32 Is this your priest?
37:33 Is this the deacons, the elders, your pastor?
37:36 Are they open?
37:38 Are they open to a conversation and say, hey, how do we do race right?
37:42 Like there are wrongs to be righted.
37:46 And part of the hatred spiritually that I think is in the US right now, I think it goes back
37:52 to the Civil War.
37:55 Because when you have that kind of thing in a nation's history, it gets in the soil, it
38:00 gets in the soul, it gets like when you have that kind of hatred.
38:07 So you see like, who am I talking to here?
38:10 Are they open to thinking about how do we do race right?
38:15 How do we say, yep, yep, we hear you.
38:20 Sometimes people just need to know you hear them.
38:23 We hear you.
38:24 We get it, yes.
38:29 If they are not open to the conversation, I think what you have to demonstrate is humility
38:36 and love.
38:38 And say, you know what, pastor, father, we don't agree, but I love you and I'm not mad
38:49 at you.
38:50 I think there's a better way to go about this, but I'm not going to force my agenda on you.
38:56 You see this guys?
38:57 Like we are walking a really difficult path ahead.
39:01 And so a big part of it is do they have ears to hear who you're talking to and what are
39:07 you trying to change?
39:08 What are you trying to secure in this moment?
39:13 Because if you listen to, let me just give you an example.
39:17 If you listen to the Wild at Heart podcast, we never make political statements.
39:27 Why?
39:28 Because in this hour, the moment that you do that, you are primarily speaking to your
39:34 own, the people that agree with you.
39:38 And if you want to speak to the people that don't agree with you, you got to keep their
39:44 ear and win over through your actions, through your love, through your involvement in the
39:50 community, et cetera, you got to win the right to be hurt.
39:55 And so because we have this global platform, that's our choice in that.
40:01 But it's not out of fear, it's out of cunning.
40:06 And then as people write into us and ask us questions, then one-on-one, we can answer
40:11 them.
40:12 And they write in.
40:13 They write in.
40:14 They ask us.
40:15 And then on a personal level, we can say, "Hey, I'm really glad you asked.
40:18 Let me share some thoughts on that."
40:20 Does that make sense?
40:21 It absolutely makes sense.
40:22 It's an hour that requires a lot of cunning, a lot of cunning.
40:25 Now, the reason why that makes sense is because I think most people, they walk into a conversation.
40:31 They're expecting an argument, first of all.
40:33 And because they're expecting an argument, they've got their talking points.
40:36 And so they're approaching a conversation like they would, a five-minute quick hit on
40:41 a seven p.m. at night news station show or something like that on Fox or MSNBC.
40:46 And they're not approaching a long-form conversation.
40:49 And even if the long-form conversation doesn't happen in that moment, it could happen over
40:53 a multitude of moments, over days, weeks, months, years, like we don't really know what
40:57 that looks like.
40:58 You might just be planning the seed of this conversation saying, "Hey, I'm listening
41:02 to you.
41:03 I want to hear your point of view.
41:04 I get the strong sense that we're going to disagree, but I want to come to some vague
41:09 sort of understanding."
41:11 And I don't know that most guys do that.
41:12 And it's because they don't have tact.
41:14 And I've encouraged guys to read Greg Hochl's book called Tactics because he takes a very
41:20 tactful approach on how to do apologetics.
41:23 And the thing is, is sometimes you could run afoul if you're having all these apologetic
41:27 arguments as coming off as like, "Oh, I know everything."
41:30 And you're just a lowly peasant who hasn't read as many books as I have.
41:33 Let me just read to you, Thomas Aquinas.
41:36 It's like, "No, no, no.
41:37 I'm not going to really get to the heart of the issue."
41:39 You think it's going to, and you're going to walk away thinking, "I made the superior
41:42 argument, but you're going to leave having not changed a mind."
41:45 Guys, I used to be that guy.
41:49 I could tell you, it doesn't work.
41:53 It doesn't work.
41:54 I was that guy.
41:56 And I was loaded for bearer, man.
41:59 Okay.
42:01 So let me give you an anecdote.
42:04 My son's 15 years old and we're in the full-till adolescent teenage confrontational years.
42:12 And he does something that totally flips my lid.
42:16 And I'm going downstairs.
42:17 He sleeps in the basement, his bedroom's in the basement.
42:20 I'm going downstairs and I'm fried.
42:23 And the thing is, guys, like, I'm brilliant at arguing.
42:26 I can, I'm supposed to be with a 15-year-old, I can win this in seven seconds.
42:30 Okay.
42:31 So I'm walking downstairs and thank God, I'm literally on my midway on the stairs.
42:38 And I breathe up a quick prayer and I said, "Jesus, what's the goal?"
42:41 And he said, "Keep communication open."
42:45 I'm like, "Right, right, right, right, right, right.
42:49 If I go down right now and lower the boom, the conversation's over, the goal is to keep
42:56 the conversation open."
42:59 That's it.
43:00 So I think even the wisdom there, John, can just be, "Hey, guys, take a second to pause."
43:04 Because it's going to take you a few seconds to get to the bedroom door knob.
43:08 So take a few seconds to pause and see if you're hearing something from God.
43:12 A couple more questions for you.
43:13 This one, you can just kind of give us a brief answer.
43:16 But you've clearly inspired a lot of people, including yours truly, with your writing.
43:21 And so my question to you is, whose writing inspires you?
43:25 Oh, I love CS Lewis.
43:29 He's like one of my all-time greats because he's brilliant at it, right?
43:35 He, he, all this, the tact, right, all of it, GK Chesterton for the same reasons.
43:44 They were brilliant, but they were cunning.
43:47 They were so winsome in their argumentation that you may know the famous story of the
43:54 London Times in Chesterton's era, the London Times invited the readers to send in their
44:00 thoughts on what is wrong with the world.
44:03 Remember this story?
44:05 It just invites in, Chesterton writes in, "Dear editor, what is wrong with the world
44:12 is me."
44:13 And it just so threw like he could, he could have shredded, he could have ripped so many
44:20 brilliant arguments, but he pointed it to human nature and he said, "What's wrong with
44:25 the world is human nature and it's in all of us.
44:27 What's wrong with the world is sin and it's in all of, anyway, they were great.
44:31 Those two guys come to mind.
44:33 Dallas Willard's been a huge influence.
44:35 I start looking at my, looking at my shelf here.
44:39 Yeah, that's it for now."
44:42 Well, hey, that's, that's a great list and guys, that's why we put together our 100 books
44:46 every modern Christian man should read list on our website.
44:49 D.S. Lewis is the only author with his own section.
44:51 Typically, the sections are parenting or money or Christianity.
44:56 There's a, wait, wait, wait, I don't have my own section on there.
44:59 Hey now, I gave a hundred bucks.
45:00 I understand that.
45:01 I understand that.
45:02 Okay.
45:03 We can have a discussion off air and we can talk about you having your own section, but
45:06 while this heart is on there and it is also bolded and highlighted, which indicates that
45:10 it's one of my top 10 favorite books.
45:12 So can we at least, you know, kind of take the pressure off a little bit?
45:15 Okay.
45:16 Fine.
45:17 I have this question here because I, I heard this quote here recently and so I was like,
45:20 okay, I got to get John's input on it.
45:22 Obviously you're, you're aware of who Jordan Peterson is.
45:25 You've talked about how a lot of guys have been fathered by some of the things that, that
45:28 you've written, right?
45:30 But you're pointing them to the father.
45:31 Jordan Peterson has kind of been a father to multitudes of boys that don't have it or
45:35 don't have that strong male influence, but he had a very poignant thing that he said
45:38 in an interview and it was this, a harmless man is not a good man.
45:43 A good man is a very, very dangerous man who has that under voluntary control.
45:51 What are your thoughts on that?
45:53 Quote.
45:54 Yep.
45:55 I'm going to make you give me a little bit more than that.
45:57 You got to give me a little bit more because I agree with you up, but give me some more.
46:03 This is what the world doesn't understand.
46:05 You see, and again, you've got to, you've got to grasp where the world's coming from.
46:10 Our prisons are not filled with young women.
46:14 Okay?
46:15 They're not.
46:16 They're filled with men.
46:17 Young women don't commit the majority of violent crimes in the world.
46:21 Young women did not commit the majority of terrorist acts.
46:24 So you have the world looks at masculinity goes, masculine is dangerous.
46:27 We got to get rid of it.
46:28 You go, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, medicine is dangerous, but you don't get rid of it.
46:34 You put it in the hands of people who know how to handle them, right?
46:38 Education is dangerous.
46:39 You don't get rid of it.
46:42 You put it in the hands of people who know how to handle it.
46:45 The same thing with masculinity, right, to have the kind of strength that allows you
46:53 to rescue your family from a burning building requires a level of risk and daring and fortitude
47:07 that is so core to masculinity.
47:10 But that same man has got to keep that under wraps when he's disciplining his children,
47:16 right?
47:17 And so, yeah, Peterson's right on that.
47:19 I agree.
47:20 It's a great quote.
47:21 And we've gone everywhere in this conversation.
47:23 This has been fantastic.
47:24 It's definitely different than the first time I'm chatted, but we went a lot of great
47:27 places.
47:28 And hey, I gained a new donor out of the deal.
47:29 So that worked out pretty well, but hey, that's all for me for now.
47:32 Is there anything else you want to get off your chest?
47:34 No, no.
47:35 Great to talk to you guys, Wild at Heart.org, the Wild at Heart experience.
47:40 It's free, six week journey.
47:43 It'll really strengthen your hearts.
47:45 It really will.
47:46 We will certainly make sure that that link is in the bio notes.
47:48 So John Eldridge, thanks for coming back on Undaunted Life of Man's Podcast.
47:53 Thanks, pal.
47:54 Great to talk to you again.
47:59 There you go, guys.
48:00 I certainly hope you enjoyed my second conversation with John Eldridge as much as I did, guys.
48:03 I'm just telling you, it was a mind-blowing conversation.
48:06 And really, he mentioned it a couple of times there, but it's like, this could be a mostly
48:09 part thing, just some of those things we were talking about, especially kind of the wokeness
48:13 in the church or kind of what to do with, you know, people wanting to emasculate young
48:16 boys and the patriarchy and LGBTQ issues, there's certainly going to be more conversations
48:21 in the future.
48:22 And we're certainly going to keep talking about here on this podcast, and I'm sure all
48:24 the guys over there at Wild at Heart will do that as well.
48:27 But before we let you guys go, we are going to do a quick resilience boost at Undaunted
48:30 Life.
48:31 We're equipping men to pushback darkness, and specifically, we hope you do that by providing
48:34 content that for just spiritual, mental, and physical resilience.
48:37 So today's resource for you is a big resource, and it's just one.
48:41 It's the Wild at Heart website.
48:42 So if you go to wild@heart.org, and again, that's going to be here in the show notes,
48:45 you can check out the Wild at Heart experience, you can check out the captivating experience,
48:49 which is the experience with Stacey, his wife, and that's more for the ladies.
48:52 And so you can give that to your wives or to people at your church.
48:54 So you can definitely check out all of that there.
48:56 Also you can link through there, go through there to go to Amazon to buy his books and
49:00 check out all the other stuff they have going on over there, including the podcast blogs,
49:03 everything else.
49:04 All right, guys.
49:05 Thanks so much for listening to this podcast.
49:06 We really do appreciate it.
49:07 Wherever you're listening to this, please subscribe, rate, and review.
49:10 If you want me to come speak at your live event or on your podcast, all you got to do
49:13 is shoot me an email info at undaunted.life.
49:15 That's I-N-F-O at undaunted.life.
49:18 You can follow us on Instagram and TikTok and like us on Facebook.
49:21 Check out our website for everything else, including how to donate to keep more content
49:24 like this coming.
49:25 Hey, guys, John became a donator right in the middle of this episode.
49:28 So if you can do it, you can do that as well.
49:30 Just go to www.undaunted.life and if you want to donate, just add a backslash donate
49:34 to there.
49:35 We also want to thank the band, August Burns Red, for allowing us to use their entire music
49:38 library for our content.
49:39 The entorato track on this podcast is our song Defender, which is off their latest record
49:43 entitled Guardians.
49:44 The links are in the description.
49:46 I'm your host, Kyle Thompson.
49:48 Remember, keep pushing back darkness, keep forging spiritual, mental, and physical resilience.
49:55 Keep seeking the Lion of Judah.
50:25 [music]
Key quotes
2
John Eldridge
We wanted no barrier to entry. We wanted just no hurdle, nothing, no other agenda in it.
Kyle Thompson
A harmless man is not a good man. A good man is a very, very dangerous man who has that under voluntary control.
Free Resource
31-Day Resilience Reset
If this episode hit, the next 31 days will be the reset. Free PDF, instant download.
START FREE →
Brotherhood
Apply to Dominion
Six pillars. Application only. The men's program Kyle built around the show.
APPLY NOW →
Dig Deeper
Ask the Archive
"Which episodes cover this topic?" Get answers grounded in all 940+ episodes.
START A CHAT →